|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready... |
There is a strange silence at the heart of this war. It is not the quiet of ceasefire. Nor the stillness of peace. It is the silence of stalemate — one that hums with drone strikes, artillery barrages, and the sound of closed diplomatic doors.
This week, the Russo-Ukrainian war entered yet another phase of escalation. On April 17 alone, Ukrainian forces reported 143 combat clashes across the front, making it one of the most violent days in recent memory. Russia launched over 3,000 kamikaze drones and more than 6,500 artillery strikes. Targets included not only military positions but also apartment buildings, hotels, and energy infrastructure in cities like Dnipro and Kherson.
Ukraine responded forcefully, striking 15 enemy targets, including command centers, artillery hubs, and drone control bases. Meanwhile, civilian deaths mounted. In Kharkiv, cluster munitions killed and injured dozens. In Kherson, 44 towns were shelled in a single day. Across the country, air raid sirens are part of daily life.
The Battlefield Map Is Redrawing, But the Political Lines Are Not
Map 1: Sumy Direction (April 17, 2025)
Map images are courtesy of the Institute for the Study of War, 2025
As seen in the Sumy Direction, Russian troops have pressed into Ukraine’s northern border regions from Kursk Oblast, with active clashes near settlements like Oleshnya, Plekhovo, and Basivka. Despite Ukrainian efforts to contain the breach, geolocated footage from April 16 confirms Russia’s slow advance toward key positions like the St. Nicholas Monastery near Guyovo.
Map 2: Entire Frontline Overview (April 17, 2025)
Map images are courtesy of the Institute for the Study of War, 2025
This broader war map reveals the overall military posture: Russia holds most of the southern and eastern regions — from Luhansk to Crimea — while Ukraine continues counteroffensives near Zaporizhzhia and Bakhmut. The war is no longer confined to one theater. There are now Ukrainian incursions into Russia’s Kursk Oblast, while Russia strengthens fortifications deep within its own borders.
Map 3: Zaporizhzhia Frontline (April 17, 2025)
Map images are courtesy of the Institute for the Study of War, 2025
In Zaporizhzhia, Russia has made small advances southeast of Mala Tokmachka, a strategic area for control over supply routes. Green circles highlight zones of heavy engagement. What these tactical movements show is clear: this war is not winding down. It is consolidating.
Neither Side Is Serious About Peace
Despite public statements to the contrary, behind closed doors, neither Ukraine nor Russia is truly negotiating. A source close to recent diplomatic outreach — who must remain anonymous for their safety — confirmed to me this week that both sides have drawn lines that leave no room for settlement.
“Neither side wants to compromise,” the source said. “Neither side has the people in place who can make peace — only the people who can survive war.”
From Moscow, Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov declared that territories in question — including Donetsk, Luhansk, and Zaporizhzhia — are
“integral parts of Russia” and “it is impossible to pose the question of their return.”
From Kyiv, President Volodymyr Zelensky insists that peace can only come “when the aggressor leaves our land.” Ukraine is not only unwilling to cede territory — it’s committed to reclaiming Crimea and striking inside Russian territory when necessary.
The Numbers Tell the Story of Stalemate
Since the full-scale invasion in February 2022, Ukrainian military estimates put Russian casualties at nearly 937,440 troops. Independent analysts suggest that combined casualties on both sides have now surpassed one million. Civilian deaths, conservatively estimated by the United Nations, are over 30,000 — likely an undercount. Millions have been displaced. Entire cities — like Mariupol and Bakhmut — have become synonymous with devastation.
And yet, neither side is acting like a nation preparing for peace. They are digging trenches. Reinforcing positions. Ramping up drone production and artillery stockpiles. This is not negotiation — it’s preparation for years more of war.
Ukraine’s Leadership Gap
It is here, reluctantly, that I offer a personal critique.
Ukraine’s leaders — brave, inspirational, and resolute — may not have the experience necessary to broker peace. Diplomacy is not the same as wartime leadership. It requires not only principle but pragmatism. Ukraine’s ministers and national security team are fighters, not statesmen. Their war cabinet is skilled at mobilizing defense and maintaining morale — but not, in my view, at engaging in the kind of painful concessions that define successful peace deals.
There is no Ukrainian version of George Marshall or Henry Kissinger. Only patriots — and they are growing tired.
Russia’s Double Game
To say that Russia is more open to negotiation is misleading. The Kremlin offers talks — but on terms no sovereign democracy could accept. Ukraine must demilitarize. NATO must retreat. Sanctions must lift. Meanwhile, Russia holds fast to occupied territories, claiming it’s “defending ethnic Russians” in the Donbas and Crimea.
Moscow’s “diplomacy” is not diplomacy. It is posturing, couched in grievance and masked as fairness.
What Is the U.S. Role?
The United States continues to support Ukraine militarily and diplomatically. But behind the scenes, frustration is mounting.
Secretary of State Marco Rubio summarized the dilemma clearly:
“If both sides want to win, and neither is prepared to yield, what we’re watching is not a negotiation — it’s a continuation of war by other means.”
The U.S. can push. It can pressure. But it cannot force peace on two governments unwilling to prioritize it.
Final Thought: Have We Talked Ourselves Out of Peace?
Wars don’t always end when one side wins. Often, they end when someone — or everyone — has lost enough to reconsider.
But in Ukraine, both sides still believe they can win. The Russians believe time is on their side. The Ukrainians believe Western support will hold. And the West continues to believe that justice requires unwavering resolve.
But justice without peace is an open wound. And peace without compromise is a fantasy.
The front lines have hardened. The diplomacy has frozen. The war that everyone talks about ending has no one truly ending it.
Join me at www.lynnscheid.com or tune into my podcast “What If I Were President?” on your favorite platform.
